Physical Address
304 North Cardinal St.
Dorchester Center, MA 02124
Comic book piracy is a well-known, decades-old problem within the comic book industry. The issue has sky-rocketed since people learned to use scanners and upload files onto the internet. While comic book piracy was once primarily a problem of scanned print issues circulating through underground sites, the rise of torrent platforms and illegal streaming sites has magnified its scale. Today, the digital age has made it easier than ever to pirate comics. A reader can buy a comic digitally and upload it to a torrent site, making it available to anyone across the globe. This contributes to a significant loss of revenue for both publishers and creators.
While comic book piracy has been a long-standing industry issue, writers and artists have voiced concerns that piracy essentially amounts to ‘stealing,’ undermining the livelihood of those who create the stories. For many, it’s not just about the loss of money but the devaluation of their work.
Comic book writer Gail Simone once said, “Piracy is not a victimless crime. It takes money from creators who work very hard on these books.” This sentiment reflects the frustration of many writers and artists who struggle to make ends meet in an industry where profits can already be thin. Simone has written for Birds of Prey, Wonder Woman, and Batgirl, all popular titles, and she argues that every lost sale impacts creators across the industry—not just in terms of immediate income but in the long-term sustainability of their careers.
Ed Brubaker, who has worked on creator-owned titles like Criminal and The Fade Out, pointed out in an interview that piracy hurts smaller creators far more than large publishers. “It’s frustrating because a lot of these people claim to be fans, but they don’t realize they’re actively preventing us from making a living,” he said. For Brubaker, who relies heavily on sales from his more niche, independent comics, piracy cuts into the funds needed to keep producing work. He’s noted how hard it is for creator-owned titles to survive in a market where they’re already competing with more mainstream superhero fare.
Another creator, Brian K. Vaughan, writer of Saga and Y: The Last Man, has echoed these concerns. He’s gone on record saying, “It’s hard to see so many people pirating Saga when we’ve worked so hard to create something special.” Vaughan has pointed out that even a hit indie title like Saga faces financial strain when fans turn to piracy instead of buying the comic legally.
An example of piracy’s staggering scale comes from the Ultimate Spider-Man series, which has garnered nearly 15 million views on a major piracy site. While someone like Brian Michael Bendis, its writer, may not personally feel the pressure because of his high status in the industry. However, for many other creators, that level of piracy would be devastating. In the UK, a single issue costs around £4. If the bulk of these readers pirated the entire run, it would represent millions of pounds in lost revenue—not just for the publisher, but for the creative team too.. This can hamper creators’ ability to continue working on their comic runs, and therefore harm their ability to create new, independent stories away from the big publishers like DC and Marvel.
However, it’s important to recognize the reasons why many readers resort to piracy. Comics, especially older or rare issues, can be incredibly difficult to find and prohibitively expensive. Some classic runs are only available in high-priced collectors’ editions or limited reprints, making them inaccessible to casual fans. For example, the scarcity of physical issues of a classic series like The Amazing Spider-Man might drive fans to seek out pirated versions just to experience the story.
Moreover, a single issue now costs over £4 and often takes only 5–10 minutes to read. I think I speak for a lot of comic book readers when I say that I want to spend much more time than this experiencing the stories I love. For some readers, especially younger fans or those from regions without strong comic book retail infrastructure, the cost is simply too high. Geographically, access to physical comics can be limited, with certain regions having no comic book stores whatsoever, especially in less developed countries and non-western territories. While digital comics are available, the price point remains a barrier for many.
Comic book piracy is undeniably damaging to the industry, creators, and publishers. It can lead to substantial financial losses and undermine the efforts of those who bring these stories to life. However, the issue is not black and white. For many, the cost and access barriers push them toward piracy as a way to engage with the medium they love. To combat piracy effectively, the industry needs to address these challenges, whether through more affordable digital options, better access to older titles, or other initiatives that can bring fans back into the fold without penalizing their wallets.
